# Red, sugar or silver maple told apart, and which to plant

> How to tell red, sugar and silver maple apart by leaf, bud and bark, what ground each takes, which suits a yard or wet spot, and other native maples to plant.

Published 2026-11-18. Tags: What to plant, How trees work. By Blue Whale Trees, a native tree nursery in the United States. Web version: https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/red-sugar-or-silver-maple/

The notch between a maple leaf's lobes tells the three apart. Red maple's notches are V-shaped and its leaf edges toothed, where sugar maple's notches are U-shaped and its edges smooth. Silver maple's notches cut deep, its lobes are coarsely toothed and the underside is silvery white. In winter, red maple carries blunt red buds and sugar maple sharp-pointed brown ones. Sugar maple wants rich, well-drained ground, red maple takes almost any site, wet ones included, and silver maple belongs on a floodplain, far from a house.

![Two deeply cut silver maple leaves on an open palm, one green and one turning yellow, over grass](https://bluewhaletrees.com/img/articles/red-sugar-or-silver-maple-1-1000.jpg?v=25298bff "Silver maple leaves on November 14, 2026, one still green and one turning yellow. The notches between the lobes cut deep, and the lobes are coarsely toothed.")
*Photo: Blue Whale Trees*

## Leaves, flowers, seeds and bark, side by side

All three set their leaves and buds in [opposite](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/glossary/index.html.md#opposite-and-alternate) pairs along the twig, which narrows a tree to [a short list](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/identify-a-broadleaf-tree-by-its-leaves/index.html.md) before any other sign. The table reads across, one sign to a row, the summer signs first and the winter ones last:

| Sign | Red maple | Sugar maple | Silver maple |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Lobes | 3, sometimes 5 | 5, rounded | 5, deeply cut |
| Leaf edges | Finely toothed | Smooth | Coarsely toothed |
| Notch between lobes | V-shaped | U-shaped | Deep |
| Underside | Whitened, sometimes hairy | Paler green | Silvery white |
| Leaf length, inches | 2–4 | 3–6 | 2.5–5 |
| Fall color | Red, orange or yellow | Brilliant yellow to burnt orange | Yellow-green |
| Flowers | Bright red, weeks before the leaves | Yellow-green, with or just before the leaves | Greenish to reddish, from as early as February |
| Seeds | 1/2 to 3/4 inch, ripe in late spring | About 1 inch, horseshoe-shaped, ripe in fall | The largest, wings 1 1/2 to 2 1/2 inches, ripe in late spring |
| Winter buds | Blunt and red, on reddish twigs | Very sharp-pointed and brown | Reddish brown, the flower buds in dense clusters |
| Young bark | Smooth and light gray | Brown, with a faint diamond pattern | Smooth and light gray |
| Old bark | Darker, in long scaly plates that peel off easily | Dark, in firm ridges curling outward, tight to the trunk | Long thin strips, loose at the ends |

## The harder calls: red or silver, and the bark

The U in sugar is the easy way to remember which notch is which. Red and silver maple are harder to part, since both have toothed leaves and reddish buds. Silver maple's lobes are cut far deeper, its underside is silvery white rather than whitened, and its crushed twig gives off an unpleasant smell. A tree whose leaves fall between theirs may be their wild cross, [the Freeman maple](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/natural-hybrids-in-native-trees/index.html.md).

A young red maple has smooth, light gray bark easily taken for [beech](https://bluewhaletrees.com/plants/american-beech/index.html.md), and silver maple starts out the same. As red maple ages, its bark breaks into narrow plates that peel off easily, while sugar maple's stays tight to the trunk even where it looks shaggy:

> "After a while one can start to get a feel for the difference in the bark between the two, but even seasoned foresters must look twice sometimes." (University of New Hampshire Extension, *Red or Sugar Maple? How do you tell the difference?*)

![Looking up into a red maple in fall, its leaves red and orange above a forked, smooth gray trunk](https://bluewhaletrees.com/img/articles/red-sugar-or-silver-maple-2-1000.jpg?v=4a04ecb4 "A red maple on October 27, 2026, its leaves turning red and orange. Its young bark is smooth and light gray, and with age it breaks into narrow plates that peel.")
*Photo: Blue Whale Trees*

A maple whose snapped leaf stalk beads milky sap is no native: it is [the invasive Norway maple](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/invasive-trees-and-the-natives-they-resemble/index.html.md#norway-maple-or-sugar-maple). For a tree you still cannot place, the [tree identification tool](https://bluewhaletrees.com/tools/identify/index.html.md) works from a photograph.

## When the seeds fall, and what comes up

Red and silver maple ripen their seeds in late spring, and the seeds can sprout as soon as they land. That is why [maple seedlings fill a yard by early summer](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/what-a-young-tree-looks-like/index.html.md). Sugar maple's seeds fall in autumn and sprout only after 35 to 90 days of moist cold, so its seedlings come up the next spring, in the North often before the snow is gone.

## Where each grows wild

Red maple is one of the most abundant and widespread trees in eastern North America. It grows on dry ridges and southwest slopes as well as in peat bogs and swamps, and in the far South it is almost wholly a swamp tree. It stands part shade, and a cut trunk sprouts freely from the stump.

![Multi-stemmed red maples in scarlet fall color at the edge of a marsh, a channel of open water among the stems](https://bluewhaletrees.com/img/articles/red-sugar-or-silver-maple-3-1000.jpg?v=6fe60b5f "Red maples in fall color at the edge of a marsh on October 22, 2026. Red maple grows in swamps and peat bogs as well as on dry ridges.")
*Photo: Blue Whale Trees*

Sugar maple is choosier. It does best on well-drained loam, often on north- and east-facing slopes, and it does not grow well on dry, shallow soil. It is rarely if ever found in a swamp. It is the more shade tolerant of the two, able to take root and grow up under a closed canopy.

Silver maple keeps to stream banks, floodplains and lake edges. Its seedlings survive long floods, and in the drier parts of its range it grows only along streams.

## Which of the three to plant

We do not grow red, sugar or silver maple. Each has a page of its own with the natives we grow for the same ground: [red maple](https://bluewhaletrees.com/species/red-maple/index.html.md), [sugar maple](https://bluewhaletrees.com/species/sugar-maple/index.html.md) and [silver maple](https://bluewhaletrees.com/species/silver-maple/index.html.md). Red and silver maple grow fast, and sugar maple grows slowly.

Sugar maple does not tolerate salt, drought or air pollution, so keep it back from a road salted in winter. It is the shade tree for rich, well-drained ground with room around it:

> "In summer, its lustrous foliage provides excellent shade, making it a great choice for parks, golf courses, and home landscapes where its roots can spread." (The Morton Arboretum, *Sugar maple*)

![A sugar maple with a full, rounded crown of orange and red fall leaves at the edge of a mowed park lawn](https://bluewhaletrees.com/img/articles/red-sugar-or-silver-maple-4-1000.jpg?v=fc0b8b5c "A sugar maple with open lawn around it in Prospect Park, Brooklyn, New York, on October 19, 2022. Its fall color runs from brilliant yellow to burnt orange.")
*Photo: Rhododendrites, [CC BY-SA 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0) ([source](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File%3ASugar_maple_tree_in_Prospect_Park_%2892375p%29.jpg))*

Red maple takes wet sites, clay and part shade. In soil of high pH its leaves can turn pale green with dark green veins, the sign of chlorosis. Its fall color varies from tree to tree, from red to orange or yellow, and [part of that is inherited](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/why-leaves-turn-red-and-yellow-in-fall/index.html.md). A wound from a broken branch or a mower's scrape often lets rot spread far into a red maple, where sugar maple walls such damage off.

Silver maple is weak-wooded and prone to storm damage, since high wind and ice break its limbs. Its roots are prone to invading sewer pipes. On a floodplain it is a fine tree, and near a house it is one of the [trees not to plant](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/trees-not-to-plant-near-a-house/index.html.md).

## The native maples we grow

Blue Whale Trees grows these native maples. The first three are sugar maple's close kin, which some botanists rank as its subspecies:

- [Black maple](https://bluewhaletrees.com/plants/black-maple/index.html.md), a sugar maple for warmer, drier ground, with nearly black furrowed bark. Zones 3 to 8, 60 to 75 feet.
- [Florida maple](https://bluewhaletrees.com/plants/florida-maple/index.html.md), the southern sugar maple, better suited to long, hot summers. Zones 5 to 9, 20 to 60 feet.
- [Chalk maple](https://bluewhaletrees.com/plants/chalk-maple/index.html.md), a small southern relative of sugar maple with chalky white bark, often on two or three trunks. Zones 5 to 9, 25 to 30 feet.
- [Striped maple](https://bluewhaletrees.com/plants/striped-maple/index.html.md), a small maple for deep, cool shade, its green bark striped in white. Zones 3 to 7, 15 to 35 feet.
- [Mountain maple](https://bluewhaletrees.com/plants/mountain-maple/index.html.md), a shade-loving small maple with upright spikes of tiny flowers in early summer. Zones 2 to 7, 10 to 25 feet.

None of the five is a tree of wet ground. [Black gum](https://bluewhaletrees.com/plants/black-gum/index.html.md) is one native we grow that shares red and silver maple's floodplains and swamps. For a small maple in place of a Japanese maple, chalk maple heads [the native replacements](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/native-replacements-for-japanese-maple-and-flowering-cherry/index.html.md). For a large shade tree with fall color, the [tree finder](https://bluewhaletrees.com/tools/tree-finder/index.html.md?size=large-tree&want=fall-color) sorts the species we grow by zone, sun and soil moisture.

## Common questions

### Is a red maple always red?

No: its leaves are green all summer, and its fall color can be yellow rather than red. The red in its name is from its buds, and its flowers, twigs and seeds carry a red tinge too.

### How do you tell a silver maple from a red maple?

Silver maple's leaves are cut far deeper, with coarse teeth and a silvery white underside, and its seed wings run 1 1/2 to 2 1/2 inches, the largest of any native maple. Its crushed twigs give off an unpleasant smell.

### Is a red maple a good tree for a yard?

Often, since it grows fast and takes wet sites, clay and part shade. Its leaves can yellow in soil of high pH, though, and a wound from a branch or a mower often lets rot spread far into the trunk.

### Will a sugar maple grow in wet soil?

Not well: sugar maple does best on well-drained loam and is rarely if ever found in a swamp. Red maple and silver maple are the maples of wet ground.

## Sources

- [Red or Sugar Maple? How do you tell the difference?](https://extension.unh.edu/blog/2024/11/red-or-sugar-maple-how-do-you-tell-difference): University of New Hampshire Extension: the V- and U-shaped notches with toothed and smooth edges, the U in sugar, red buds and tan ones, red maple's smooth young bark and peeling plates against sugar maple's tight bark, the bark sentence quoted, shade and sprouting, sugar maple's soils and slopes, and wounds walled off or not.
- [Red maple, Acer rubrum](https://dendro.cnre.vt.edu/dendrology/syllabus/factsheet.cfm?ID=1): Virginia Tech Dendrology, with its fact sheets for sugar maple and silver maple: the lobes, edges, undersides and lengths of the leaves, the flowers, seed sizes and seasons, twigs and buds, and young and old bark of the three.
- [Sugar maple](https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sugar-maple/): The Morton Arboretum, with its pages for red maple and silver maple: the fall colors of the three, sugar maple's shade and room for roots in the quotation, its intolerance of salt, drought and air pollution, red maple's chlorosis in high pH soil, its red tinge and its tolerance of wet sites and clay, and silver maple's weak wood, broken limbs and roots in sewer pipes.
- [Red Maple](https://research.fs.usda.gov/silvics/red-maple): USDA Forest Service, Silvics of North America: red maple among the most abundant and widespread eastern trees, on sites from dry ridges to peat bogs and swamps, almost wholly a swamp tree in the far South, its early flowers and seeds that sprout at once.
- [Sugar Maple](https://research.fs.usda.gov/silvics/sugar-maple): USDA Forest Service, Silvics of North America: well-drained loam and not dry, shallow soil or swamps, and the 35 to 90 days of moist cold its seeds need.
- [Silver Maple](https://research.fs.usda.gov/silvics/silver-maple): USDA Forest Service, Silvics of North America: stream banks, floodplains and lake edges, seedlings that survive long floods, streamsides only in the drier parts of its range, the first maple to bloom, from as early as February, and seeds ripe from April to June that sprout at once.

## Related

- Next step: [Open the tree finder](https://bluewhaletrees.com/tools/tree-finder/index.html.md?size=large-tree&want=fall-color)
- [Native replacements for Japanese maple, flowering cherry, crape myrtle, Norway maple and Norway spruce](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/native-replacements-for-japanese-maple-and-flowering-cherry/index.html.md)
- [Why leaves turn red and yellow in fall, and which native trees give each color](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/why-leaves-turn-red-and-yellow-in-fall/index.html.md)
- [Tapping a native maple for syrup](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/tapping-a-native-maple-for-syrup/index.html.md)
- [Six trees not to plant near a house, and what to plant instead](https://bluewhaletrees.com/articles/trees-not-to-plant-near-a-house/index.html.md)
