Blue Whale Trees
Find my tree

Green, white, black and blue ash told apart, and whether to plant one now

By · Published · 6 min read

Which ash tree you have, read from its leaf scars, leaflets, twigs and seeds, which ashes the emerald ash borer kills, and the one native ash worth planting.

On this page Five ashes side by sideAn ash or a look-alikeGreen ash or white ashBlack, blue and pumpkin ashWhich ashes the emerald ash borer killsShould you plant an ash nowCommon questionsSources

An ash sets its leaves in pairs, and each leaf is cut into 5 to 11 leaflets. To tell green ash from white ash, look under a side bud. White ash’s leaf scar is U-shaped and wraps partly around the bud, while green ash’s is straight or shallowly notched across the top, with the bud sitting on it. Black ash has stalkless leaflets and grows in bogs, and blue ash has four-angled twigs. Green and black ash die of the emerald ash borer and white ash often does, but most blue ash survive it, so blue ash is the one native ash to plant now.

Gray-green ash twig held between two fingers, a crescent leaf scar curving up around the stub of a side bud
A white ash leaf scar on June 30, 2017, notched at the top around the stub of its side bud. A green ash bud sits on top of a scar that is straight or barely notched. Photo: Michael Ellis, CC BY 4.0 (source)

Five ashes side by side

The table sets five eastern ashes side by side, in alphabetical order. We grow blue ash. Green, white, black and pumpkin ash are trees we do not grow. Each has a page of its own.

Ash Leaflets Twig and leaf scar Seed Where it grows
Black ash 7 to 11, stalkless Round leaf scar; buds nearly black Wide wing, flat seed Bogs and wet ground in the North
Blue ash 7 to 11, toothed Four-angled, often winged; scars notched Wide wing, flat seed Glades and bluff tops, often on limestone
Green ash 7 to 9, short-stalked, not whitened beneath Scar flat or shallowly notched, the bud on top Slender, thin seed River bottoms and stream banks
Pumpkin ash 7 to 9, large, velvety beneath Fuzzy twig; oval scar, not deeply notched 2 to 3 inches, the largest Swamps and river bottoms
White ash Usually 7, clearly stalked, whitish beneath U-shaped scar notched around the bud Plump, rounded seed Rich, moist upland soils

Bark does not tell green ash from white ash, since both grow gray bark whose corky ridges interlace in diamonds. Black ash bark turns scaly to corky, and blue ash bark breaks into irregular fissures and scaly ridges.

A hand gripping a young black ash trunk in snow, its bark broken into small, rough, corky ridges
A young black ash with its corky bark, on October 7, 2011. Black ash bark starts smooth and turns scaly to corky, unlike the diamond ridges of white and green ash. Photo: Rob Routledge, Sault College, Bugwood.org, CC BY 3.0 US (source)

An ash or a look-alike

Many trees carry leaves cut into leaflets, and the first sign of an ash is that its leaves grow in opposite pairs, not one at a time as on the hickories and walnuts. A crushed hickory or walnut leaf also smells spicy or strong, and a crushed ash leaf does not. American mountain ash, of the rose family, sets its leaves one at a time too, each with 11 to 17 leaflets, and bears clusters of small red fruits like tiny apples.

Boxelder, which we do not grow, is the hard case: a maple whose leaves come in pairs and are cut into 3 to 5 leaflets, sometimes 7. Its twigs are green to purplish, often with a whitish bloom, and its seeds hang in V-shaped pairs. Buds keep the leaves’ pairs in winter, as winter identification shows, and the tree identification tool names a tree from a photograph of a leaf or a twig.

Green ash or white ash

The leaf scar settles it once the leaves have fallen. A white ash bud sits down in the notch of a U-shaped scar, and a green ash bud sits on top of a scar that is flat or barely notched.

Brown ash bud perched on top of a pale, shield-shaped leaf scar on a gray twig, lit against a black background
A green ash side bud on August 6, 2015, sitting on top of its leaf scar rather than down in a notch, as a white ash bud does. Photo: Bruce Kirchoff, CC BY 2.0 (source)

In summer the leaflets help. White ash leaflets are clearly stalked and whitish beneath, while green ash leaflets have short stalks and no whitened underside. White ash’s seed is plump and rounded below its wing, and green ash’s is slender. Their wood is alike, and green ash lumber is sold as white ash.

White ash often turns purple or reddish brown in fall, and green ash mostly yellow. That purple is a color the borer is taking from the woods:

“In our fall color landscapes, we will especially miss the unique, rich plum-reddish-purple color of white ash in the years to come.” (Missouri Department of Conservation, Ashes)

Black, blue and pumpkin ash

Black ash is the ash of northern bogs, stream banks and seasonally flooded ground. Its leaflets have no stalks and its buds are nearly black. Its wood splits easily and has long been made into baskets.

Blue ash has stout twigs, four-angled and square in cross-section, the angles sometimes with narrow corky wings. Its leaflets are toothed, 7 to 11 to a leaf, and unlike most ashes its flowers usually carry both male and female parts. Settlers mashed its inner bark in water for a blue dye, which gave the tree its name.

Drooping blue ash leaflets with toothed edges and pale veins, a gray trunk out of focus behind them
Blue ash leaflets at Dawes Arboretum in Licking County, Ohio, on July 5, 2008. Blue ash carries 7 to 11 toothed leaflets to a leaf. Photo: James St. John, CC BY 2.0 (source)

Pumpkin ash grows in swamps and river bottoms, chiefly on the Coastal Plain from southern Maryland to northern Florida and west to Louisiana. Where water stands around it, the base of its trunk swells like a pumpkin.

Which ashes the emerald ash borer kills

The emerald ash borer is a beetle from Asia whose larvae feed under the bark, and all 16 native ashes are susceptible, healthy trees of any size among them. By November 2026 it had been found in 38 states and the District of Columbia. In a Michigan common garden planted in 2007 and opened to the beetle in 2012, the toll differed by species:

  • Black ash. Every tree was dead by fall 2013, after two seasons of the beetle.
  • Green ash. 63 percent had died by August 2022.
  • White ash. 12 percent had died by August 2022.
  • Blue ash. The beetle killed none, and all 26 trees left were alive and appeared healthy in August 2022.

The woods agree. In two southeast Michigan woodlots, after a decade or more of heavy beetle numbers, every white ash died while more than 60 percent of the blue ash stayed healthy. At six more sites there in 2015, 68 to 93 percent of the blue ash were alive, against 17 to 56 percent of the white ash.

Blue ash is attacked all the same. Female beetles are thought to find it less attractive for their eggs, and the tree is better able to stop the larvae. In Missouri, the crowns of mature blue ash on thin soils that often run dry have died back, while large trees on better soil grow beside white ash the beetle killed years ago. The signs of an infested ash and its treatment are in borers in a young or stressed tree.

Should you plant an ash now

Plant no green, white, black or pumpkin ash. The young ashes that sprout where old ones died are likely to be killed once they reach a certain size, and the University of Minnesota Extension recommends planting no more ash of any kind. A healthy ash already in the yard is worth keeping, and treatment can protect it.

Ash seedlings’ compound leaves over fallen leaves, each of several toothed, short-stalked leaflets
Ash seedlings on November 1, 2026. Young ashes like these are likely to be killed by the emerald ash borer once they reach a certain size. Photo: Blue Whale Trees

The researchers who followed blue ash through the Michigan outbreak see it differently:

“Given the persistence of healthy blue ash in areas initially invaded by EAB 15 to 20 yr ago, this native species warrants consideration as a viable tree for urban forests and perhaps for restoration efforts in post-invasion sites.” (Mathieu and McCullough, Long-term survival and radial growth of four North American and two Asian ash species in a common garden exposed to emerald ash borer invasion, 2025)

Blue ash is the one native ash we would plant now, as one tree among several kinds rather than a row of one. Give it full sun and dry to average ground. It takes drought, heat and alkaline soil better than white or green ash. Young trees still need watching for the beetle. Blue Whale Trees grows blue ash from seed, one of our uncommon yard trees.

Common questions

How do you tell green ash from white ash?

Look under a side bud: white ash’s leaf scar is U-shaped and notched around the bud, while green ash’s is straight or shallowly notched, with the bud on top. White ash leaflets are also whitish beneath.

Are any ash trees resistant to emerald ash borer?

Blue ash is the most resistant native ash: the beetle attacks it, but most blue ash survive where green and black ash die and white ash often does. Among the Asian ashes, Manchurian ash resists it, while Chinese ash does not.

What tree looks like an ash tree?

Boxelder is the likeliest, since its leaves also come in pairs cut into leaflets, but its seeds hang in V-shaped pairs like a maple’s. Hickories, walnuts and American mountain ash carry leaflets too. Their leaves grow one at a time along the twig.

Are there male and female ash trees?

Yes: most ash trees are either male or female, so only the female trees bear seeds. Blue ash is the exception, since its flowers usually carry both male and female parts.

Share Copy link Email this article

Catalog

Browse the trees we grow

Rare oaks, uncommon yard trees, native shrubs and seed from proven parent trees, all grown from seed.

See the catalog

Shipping windows, newly priced plants and new articles. Four to six emails a year, and nothing else.

Sources

(9 references)
  • Ashes: Missouri Department of Conservation: the quotation on white ash’s fall color, opposite leaves of mostly 5 to 11 leaflets, the leaf scars of white and green ash, crushed hickory and walnut leaves against an ash’s, the mountain ashes of the rose family, blue ash’s square twigs and corky wings, its flowers, glades and blue dye, pumpkin ash’s large fruits, and male and female trees.
  • Fraxinus comparison chart: University of Wisconsin-Green Bay Herbarium: white ash’s clearly stalked leaflets with whitened undersides against green ash’s short stalks and black ash’s stalkless leaflets, and white ash’s purplish or reddish brown fall color against the yellow of green and black ash.
  • White ash: Virginia Tech Dendrology, with its fact sheets for green ash, black ash, blue ash, pumpkin ash, boxelder and American mountain ash: the leaflets, leaf scars, buds, seeds and bark of the table and the bark paragraph, and the leaves, twigs and fruit of boxelder and American mountain ash.
  • Green Ash: USDA Forest Service, Silvics of North America, with its chapters White Ash, Black Ash and Pumpkin Ash: green ash on bottomlands and stream banks and its wood sold as white ash, white ash on rich, moist soils, black ash in bogs, along streams and on seasonally flooded ground and its wood split for baskets, and pumpkin ash’s swamps, range and swollen butt.
  • Long-term survival and radial growth of four North American and two Asian ash species in a common garden exposed to emerald ash borer invasion: Mathieu and McCullough, Environmental Entomology 54 (2025): the quotation on planting blue ash, the Michigan common garden planted in 2007 and its losses by species to 2022, the Michigan woodlots and post-invasion sites, Manchurian and Chinese ash, and the Missouri blue ash on thin, droughty soils.
  • Emerald Ash Borer (EAB) FAQs for Kentuckians: University of Kentucky Entomology: blue ash attacked yet more resistant and why, young ash regeneration likely killed once it reaches a certain size, and treatment as the way to protect an ash.
  • Emerald ash borer: The Morton Arboretum: all 16 native ash species susceptible, healthy trees of any size among them, and larvae feeding under the bark.
  • Emerald Ash Borer: USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service: a beetle from Asia, found in 38 states and the District of Columbia when read on November 18, 2026.
  • Emerald ash borer: University of Minnesota Extension: a healthy ash in the yard kept, and the recommendation to plant no more ash.

Keep reading

Related articles

All articles