Bumps and galls on tree leaves: maple, hackberry, elm, hickory and witch hazel, and which ones matter
Why red bumps, spindles and velvet appear on maple leaves, how to tell a gall from tar spot, rust or scale, and which galls are worth pruning or treating.
On this page
Red bumps, spindles and velvet on maple leavesNipple galls on hackberry leavesCones and spiny buds on witch hazelCockscombs and pouches on elm leavesRound galls on hickory leaves and twigsWhen a gall mattersGall, leaf spot, rust or scaleWhat to do about leaf gallsCommon questionsSourcesThe small bumps, cones and velvety patches on the leaves of maples, hackberries, elms, hickories and witch hazel are galls. A gall is the leaf’s own tissue, grown around a mite or an insect that feeds inside it, and on these trees galls seldom do lasting harm. They form in spring as the new leaves expand, and once a gall shows, its maker is sealed inside, out of reach of any spray. Most years the right thing to do is nothing.

Red bumps, spindles and velvet on maple leaves
Red bumps on a red or silver maple are most often maple bladder galls, round warts a sixteenth to an eighth of an inch across on the upper side of the leaf. A mite too small to see without magnification raises them, and they show first in May, as the leaves reach full size. They start green, soon turn pink to red and end up black. A leaf can carry so many that it twists out of shape and drops early.
Sugar maple carries spindle galls instead, thin upright spindles that a second mite raises and that seldom distort the leaf. Crimson to yellow patches like velvet are erineum, a dense growth of fine leaf hairs raised by other mites, most often on silver maple and boxelder. All three mites winter under loose bark and around wounds and pruning scars. At bud break they crawl to the opening buds, where their feeding raises a blister that swells into a hollow gall around them.

Nipple galls on hackberry leaves
Knobby galls under a hackberry leaf, each marked by a blistered spot on the upper side, are nipple galls, and almost every hackberry carries some. They turn up on common hackberry, sugarberry and dwarf hackberry alike. Hackberry psyllids make them: jumping plant lice less than a quarter inch long that look like tiny cicadas. Females lay eggs on the young leaves in spring, and the leaf forms a gall around each feeding nymph.
In late summer or early fall the winged adults leave the galls to find a place for the winter. They gather on window screens, sometimes in large numbers, and are small enough to pass through most screens, though they are harmless to people. Weather stripping and caulk keep them out of a house, and so do windows kept closed while they are about.

Cones and spiny buds on witch hazel
Cones rising from a witch hazel leaf are the galls of the witch hazel cone gall aphid. Its eggs pass the winter on the shrub, and the young aphids that hatch in spring make the leaf grow a cone around them, inside which they feed and multiply. In late spring or early summer they leave the cones for birch leaves.
A spiny gall at a bud belongs to a second aphid. It starts as a green, fleshy knob and hardens into a brown, spiky one by winter. That aphid spends part of its life on birch, where it pleats the leaves, above all on river birch.

Cockscombs and pouches on elm leaves
A wrinkled ridge like a rooster’s comb, standing up from the upper side of an elm leaf, is an elm cockscomb gall. One to several can sit on a leaf of American elm or slippery elm, and the aphid that makes them leaves the gall to feed on the roots of grasses. Long pouches on the upper side of elm leaves, often reddish and in a heavy year many to a leaf, are slippery elm pouch galls, also called sack galls, made by another aphid. They appear in May and soon fill with female aphids and their young.

Round galls on hickory leaves and twigs
Most hickory galls are raised by phylloxerans, close relatives of aphids. The hickory leaf stem gall is a round, irregular growth on a leaf, a leaf stalk or a twig. Its eggs winter in bark crevices and hatch as the buds open, and the young raise the galls with their feeding. A winged generation grows up inside, and by the end of June the galls dry and open and the insects fly. Other phylloxerans make disks, buttons or beads on the leaves, and the same genus galls pecan too. Heavily galled leaves may turn yellow-brown and drop.

When a gall matters
A leaf gall mars the look of a tree’s leaves, and a heavy crop can make them drop early. Maple galls can run heavy after a mild winter:
“Following a mild winter, damage from these leaf galls can be excessive, but affected trees often send out new leaves to replace the damaged ones.” (Ohio State University Extension, Galls of Maple Trees in Ohio)
A tree that looks unhealthy beyond its galls points to another problem, such as a disease or poor growing conditions. The spiny witch hazel gall aphid can drop river birch leaves early and kill twigs and branches, and a young or heavily hit birch may need a spray of horticultural oil. Woody galls that girdle twigs can kill the branch beyond them, the subject of wasp galls on oaks.
Gall, leaf spot, rust or scale
A gall is part of the leaf, so it cannot be picked or scraped off, and it is often hollow, with a mite or an insect inside. Velvety erineum can pass for a fungus or a disease. Spots, blotches and the black crusts of tar spot are not galls, and spots, powder and speckles on tree leaves sorts them out.

Orange spots on a hawthorn or serviceberry, and brown galls on a cedar that swell into orange horns, are cedar rusts, the work of a fungus. Small brown, gray or white bumps crusted on twigs and leaves are scale insects, each living under a waxy or hard cover of its own.
What to do about leaf galls
Leave them. A spray after the galls show cannot reach the mite or insect inside, and it upsets the predators and parasites that keep gall makers in check. Many of those natural enemies live in the galls, so even where you cut some out, leave a few. Most years the galls come and go on their own:
“Your best management tool is patience. Most galls will not kill a tree and tend to cycle through times when they are abundant and times when they are rare.” (Purdue Extension Entomology, Galls on Shade Trees and Shrubs)
Where a spray is wanted, the only window is early spring, as the buds swell and the gall makers move to the new leaves. Sources split on using it. Purdue times a dormant oil to the swelling buds, when bladder gall mites crawl out onto the bud scales. Ohio State discourages oil on maples, which it can injure unless the tree is fully dormant.
Beyond that:
- Prune heavily galled twigs on a small tree and bag them, to lower next season’s mites.
- Pick up galled hickory twigs that fall in summer and destroy them.
- Keep the tree healthy with enough water and fertile soil.
- Still unsure what you have: Blue Whale Trees answers questions about a tree you already have through its support page. A photo of the whole tree, a close-up of the galls and a note on when they appeared help it answer quickly.
Common questions
What are the red bumps on my maple leaves?
Most often maple bladder galls, which a mite too small to see raises on red and silver maple leaves in spring. They start green, turn red and then black, and seldom do the tree lasting harm.
How do I get rid of galls on maple leaves?
Once a gall forms, it is part of the leaf, and no spray reaches the mites inside. The only window is early spring as the buds swell, and sources differ on dormant oil for maples.
What are the bumps on hackberry leaves?
Nipple galls, each grown around the nymph of a hackberry psyllid, a jumping plant louse under a quarter inch long. The adults that leave them in late summer or fall are the tiny bugs on window screens.
Do leaf galls hurt a tree?
Seldom: a leaf gall mars the look of the leaves and, in a heavy year, can make them drop early. The spiny witch hazel gall aphid on river birch and the galls that girdle twigs are the exceptions worth acting on.
Sources
(8 references)
- Galls of Maple Trees in Ohio: Ohio State University Extension, Ohioline (David J. Shetlar and Jennifer E. Andon, ENT-60): galls as leaf tissue grown around a feeding mite or insect, bladder galls of 1/16 to 1/8 inch on red and silver maples from May and their colors, twisted leaves and early leaf drop, spindle galls on sugar maple, crimson to yellow erineum on silver maple and boxelder taken for a fungus or a disease, the mites’ winter under loose bark and around wounds, the blister at the opening buds, galls drying by midsummer, heavy damage after a mild winter and the quotation, control generally not recommended, sprays too late once galls form, oil on maples discouraged, pruning and bagging, and plant health.
- Galls Made by Aphids, Adelgids, Phylloxerans, Psyllids, and Midges: Virginia Cooperative Extension (Eric Day and Theresa A. Dellinger), with its fact sheet Galls and Rust made by Mites (ENTO-147): elm cockscomb galls on American and slippery elm and their aphid on grass roots, slippery elm pouch galls in May, the hickory leaf stem gall’s eggs, hatch, winged generation and June exit, other phylloxerans’ disks, buttons and beads, galls on pecan, erineum as dense velvety leaf hairs, and pruning heavily galled parts to lower the mites for the coming seasons.
- Galls on Shade Trees and Shrubs: Purdue Extension Entomology (Clifford S. Sadof and Timothy J. Gibb, E-56): galls that cannot be removed because they are part of the leaf, hollow bladder galls, the bladder gall mites on the bud scales as the buds swell and dormant oil then, most hickory galls made by phylloxera and yellow-brown leaves that drop, natural enemies living in galls and a few galls left for them, twig galls that girdle and kill branch tips, and the quotation.
- Tree and Shrub Galls: University of Maryland Extension (John A. Davidson, revised by Mary Kay Malinoski): other causes behind an unhealthy galled tree, the spiny witch hazel gall aphid on river birch, its pleated leaves, early leaf drop and dead twigs and branches, and horticultural oil for a young or heavily hit birch.
- Deciduous Tree Galls: University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (P.J. Liesch and R. Chris Williamson): eriophyid mites seen only under magnification, hackberry psyllids slipping through window screens in fall, weather stripping, caulk and closed windows to keep them out, and the predators and parasitoids of gall makers.
- Hackberry Psyllids (Hackberry Nipple Gall Makers): Missouri Department of Conservation, Field Guide: psyllids under a quarter inch that look like tiny cicadas, eggs on young leaves in spring, galls formed around feeding nymphs, blistered spots on the upper side of the leaf, winged adults leaving in late summer or early fall, adults on window screens in large numbers, and their harmlessness to people.
- Witchhazel Leaf Gall Aphid: NC State Extension: cone-shaped galls on witch hazel from eggs that hatch in spring, aphids feeding and multiplying inside, and their flight to birch in late spring or early summer.
- Common Shade Tree Galls: University of Kentucky Entomology, with its Tree Pest Guide page Witch-hazel: nearly every hackberry carrying some nipple galls, sprays that upset the natural enemies of gall makers, and the spiny witch hazel gall in the buds, green and fleshy and then brown and spiky by winter, its aphid also found on birch.


