Blue Whale Trees
Find my tree

Native replacements for Japanese maple, flowering cherry, crape myrtle, Norway maple and Norway spruce

By · Published · 8 min read

Why gardeners pass over five popular imported trees, which one some states ban, and the native that does each one's job, from fall color to an evergreen screen.

On this page Which of the five are invasiveJapanese maple: a small maple for fall colorFlowering and weeping cherries: blossoms on bare branchesCrape myrtle: flowers through the summerNorway maple: dense shade on a tough treeNorway spruce: a dark evergreen screenChoosing the native for your groundCommon questionsSources

A small native maple does a Japanese maple’s job, and a redbud, serviceberry or wild plum does a flowering cherry’s. Chalk maple turns yellow, orange and deep red in fall, and eastern redbud flowers magenta on bare branches before its leaves. For crape myrtle’s summer flowers, the Franklin tree blooms from July until frost. Black maple casts a Norway maple’s dense shade, and red spruce or eastern hemlock makes the dark screen of a Norway spruce. Of the five imports, only Norway maple is banned from sale, in several states.

A white Franklin tree flower with five rounded petals around a boss of orange-yellow stamens, a bumblebee feeding
A Franklin tree in flower in September 2023. It blooms from midsummer until the first frost, each flower about 3 inches across. Photo: Shuvaev, CC BY 4.0 (source)

The trait each import was planted for, and the natives we grow that carry it:

Native In place of The trait it carries Zones Height, feet
Chalk maple Japanese maple Yellow to deep red fall color 5–9 25–30
Striped maple Japanese maple Striped bark, in shade 3–7 15–35
Eastern redbud Flowering cherry Magenta flowers on bare branches 4–9 20–30
Allegheny serviceberry Flowering cherry White flowers in April 3–9 15–25
Mexican plum Flowering cherry Fragrant white flowers 5–9 10–35
Franklin tree Crape myrtle Flowers from July until frost 5–9 10–25
Sourwood Crape myrtle Summer flowers, crimson fall leaves 5–9 25–50
American smoketree Crape myrtle Summer smoke on dry ground 3–8 20–30
Black maple Norway maple A dense, rounded crown 3–8 60–75
American basswood Norway maple Deep shade 2–8 60–90
Red spruce Norway spruce A tall spruce for cool ground 2–6 60–75
Eastern hemlock Norway spruce An evergreen screen in shade 3–7 40–100

Which of the five are invasive

Norway maple is the one with a legal record. Seventeen states class it as invasive, and New Hampshire and Massachusetts ban its sale. Maine has barred its sale since January 1, 2018. Connecticut’s ban takes effect in October 2030 and New Jersey’s on January 1, 2030. New York allows its sale only under a warning label.

Japanese maple comes next. It self-seeds, and NC State Extension’s plant database reports a regional listing:

“It self-seeds easily so can spread and become weedy in the landscape. The Mid-Atlantic Pest Council lists it as invasive in VA and DC.” (NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Acer palmatum)

Virginia’s own invasive plant list of 2024 ranks Norway maple’s invasiveness as medium but does not name Japanese maple. Nor do the lists of Connecticut, Maine, New Hampshire, New Jersey and New York. None of the six names a flowering cherry, crape myrtle or Norway spruce either.

The four are passed over for what they lack and for their troubles in a yard. A yard of Japanese maple, crape myrtle and Bradford pear feeds a fraction of the moths a yard of natives does.

Japanese maple: a small maple for fall color

Japanese maple comes from Korea and Japan. It is planted for a low, layered crown of hand-shaped leaves, deep red and orange in summer and deeper in fall. It wants dappled shade and evenly moist soil.

Chalk maple is the nearest native match, a small maple often on two or three trunks, whose leaves turn yellow, orange and deep red in fall. It grows in sun, part shade or deep shade, in soil that drains well. It tolerates dry soil, though in full sun it needs water through a dry summer.

Striped maple suits the North and deep shade. Its green bark, striped in white, stands out all winter, and its leaves turn bright yellow in fall. It needs a cool, moist, acid soil, scorches in full sun and struggles in hot southern summers. Neither maple has red leaves in summer, so both save their color for fall.

Smooth green young stem of a striped maple marked with long, thin white stripes running up its length
The young stem of a striped maple on May 4, 2011. Its white-striped bark gives it the name snakebark maple and stands out in winter. Photo: Bill Cook, Michigan State University, Bugwood.org, CC BY 3.0 (source)

Flowering and weeping cherries: blossoms on bare branches

Japanese flowering cherries come from China, Japan and Korea and are planted for white or pink spring flowers, single or double. Most cultivars bear no fruit, and the tree usually lives 15 to 20 years. Its thin bark is easily damaged, and borers, cankers and black knot are among its many troubles.

Eastern redbud flowers magenta straight from the bark in early spring, before the leaves. It takes sun or part shade and dry ground or clay, but not standing water, and it is short-lived too, at 20 to 25 years.

Allegheny serviceberry opens white flowers in April and ripens the sweetest fruit of the serviceberries in June. It does best where summers stay cool, in evenly moist soil.

Mexican plum belongs to the cherries’ own genus, Prunus, and opens fragrant white flowers in March and April, before the leaves. It grows on one trunk without suckering, on almost any well-drained soil, but its ripe plums drop and make a mess beside a patio.

A weeping cherry’s habit comes from its cultivars. Where winters are mild, in zones 8 to 9, weeping hawthorn has slender branches that weep strongly and white flowers in March and April. It grows on dry, sandy ground.

Crape myrtle: flowers through the summer

Crape myrtle comes from southern and eastern Asia. It flowers from July to September, its bark peels to show brown and gray, and it takes full sun, drought and deer. Crapemyrtle bark scale now troubles it, hiding under white felt on the bark while sooty mold grows on the honeydew the scales excrete. Topping should never be needed to keep it small.

The Franklin tree comes closest in bloom. Its fragrant white flowers, about 3 inches across, open from July until frost, and its leaves turn orange, red and purple in fall. It needs acid soil that stays moist but drains freely, since wet ground rots the roots, and it tends to be short-lived in gardens.

Sourwood hangs drooping sprays of white flowers from late June into August, and its leaves turn crimson as early as September. It needs acid soil that drains, away from compaction and salt, so plant it in a bed rather than a lawn strip.

American smoketree shares crape myrtle’s ease in sun and drought. Its spent flower clusters turn smoky pink through summer, its gray-brown bark breaks into scaly plates with age, and its leaves turn orange, scarlet and purple at once in October. It asks for full sun and sharp drainage and will not stand wet or heavy soil.

Gray-brown trunk of an American smoketree broken into small scaly plates flecked with lichen, with leaves behind
An American smoketree's gray-brown bark, broken into small scaly plates, on October 31, 2026. Photo: Blue Whale Trees

Norway maple: dense shade on a tough tree

Norway maple came from Europe in 1756 as an ornamental, and towns planted it for its hardiness and generous shade. It takes heat, cold, drought, compacted soil and pollution. Its dense canopy and shallow roots leave little room beneath it, and it seeds heavily:

“Due to excessive seeding, Norway maple is able to shade out native wildflowers in wooded areas and may even be able to outcompete native trees and shrubs.” (The Morton Arboretum, Norway maple)

Black maple, a close relative of sugar maple, grows a dense, rounded crown and turns yellow, sometimes orange and red, in fall. It takes alkaline soil and stands heat and drought a little better than sugar maple, but road salt, severe drought and polluted air harm it. American basswood casts deep shade under big heart-shaped leaves, and its fragrant June flowers draw bees. It tolerates cold, shade and clay, but does poorly in city conditions and on thin, droughty ground.

Neither matches Norway maple in a city, so for a tree lawn beside a busy street, choose among the native street trees. A Norway maple already in the yard is told from a native maple by the milky sap of a snapped leaf stalk.

Norway spruce: a dark evergreen screen

Norway spruce comes from Europe and grows fast into a needled evergreen 40 to 60 feet tall, a windbreak or screen where winters are cold. It prefers cool summers and does poorly in zone 7 in the South. Aphids, bagworms, budworms, borers and spider mites feed on it, and the white pine weevil attacks it too.

Red spruce is the native spruce of the Northeast and the high Appalachians, narrow and long-lived. It needs a cool, moist climate and acid soil that drains, and it dislikes summer heat. Set 12 feet apart, a group makes an evergreen screen and nesting cover for birds.

Eastern hemlock grows dark and feathery, even in deep shade, sheared as a hedge or left as a tall screen. It wants moist, acid soil and stands neither drought, soggy ground nor salt spray. The hemlock woolly adelgid, a tiny insect from Asia, kills an untreated tree within several years, and a soil treatment gives good control.

Both natives grow more slowly than Norway spruce, and eastern hemlock adds about a foot a year in our growth estimator. Where summers run hot, the evergreens in native hedges, screens and windbreaks take the job.

Choosing the native for your ground

Blue Whale Trees grows every native in the table from seed. Start from the job the old tree did, then add your zone, sun and soil moisture in the tree finder:

Common questions

What is a native alternative to a Japanese maple?

Chalk maple, a small maple whose leaves turn yellow, orange and deep red in fall, in sun or shade. In the North and in deep shade, striped maple turns bright yellow and shows green bark striped in white.

What can I plant instead of a weeping cherry?

Eastern redbud or Mexican plum, for flowers on bare branches in spring, or Allegheny serviceberry, white in April. Where winters are mild, in zones 8 to 9, weeping hawthorn has strongly weeping branches and white flowers in March and April.

What is a native alternative to crape myrtle?

The Franklin tree, whose fragrant white flowers open from July until frost, on acid soil that stays moist but drains. Sourwood flowers from late June into August, and American smoketree takes sun and drought as crape myrtle does.

Is Norway spruce invasive?

Norway spruce is not on the invasive plant lists of Connecticut, Maine, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York or Virginia as they read in November 2026. Where summers stay cool, red spruce is the native spruce to plant in its place.

Share Copy link Email this article

Tool

Find the right tree for the spot

Filter everything we grow by hardiness zone, mature size, sun, soil and what you want the plant to do.

Open the tree finder

Shipping windows, newly priced plants and new articles. Four to six emails a year, and nothing else.

Sources

(11 references)
  • Acer palmatum: NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, with the pages for Acer platanoides, Prunus serrulata, Prunus x yedoensis, Lagerstroemia indica, Picea abies, Cercis canadensis, Franklinia alatamaha, Acer leucoderme and Acer pensylvanicum: Norway maple’s tolerance of heat, cold, drought, urban conditions and pollution, its dense canopy and shallow roots, Japanese maple’s origin, crown, summer color, site and the quotation on self-seeding, the flowering cherries’ origin, flowers, fruitless cultivars, weeping cultivars, life span and troubles, crape myrtle’s origin, bloom, bark, site and topping, Norway spruce’s origin, growth, size, use, poor growth in zone 7 and pests, redbud flowering before its leaves, the Franklin tree’s bloom from midsummer to frost and its 3-inch flowers, the summer leaf colors of chalk and striped maple, and striped maple’s bark.
  • Crapemyrtle Bark Scale: NC State Extension, PDIC Factsheets: the scale’s white felted covering on crape myrtle bark and the sooty mold that grows on its honeydew.
  • Norway maple: The Morton Arboretum: Norway maple as an invasive plant and the quotation on its seeding and the wildflowers it shades out.
  • Invasives in Your Woodland: Norway Maple: University of Maryland Extension (Andrew Kling): Norway maple’s introduction in 1756, its planting for hardiness and shade, its tolerance of compacted soil, the bans in New Hampshire and Massachusetts, and the seventeen states that class it as invasive.
  • Chapter Agr 3800, Invasive Species: New Hampshire Department of Agriculture, Markets and Food: Norway maple on the state’s prohibited invasive species list, which no one may buy, sell or propagate.
  • Massachusetts Prohibited Plant List: Massachusetts Department of Agricultural Resources: Norway maple on the state’s list of plants whose sale, import, trade, purchase, distribution and propagation are prohibited.
  • Invasive Plants: Maine Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Forestry, Horticulture Program: Norway maple on the Do Not Sell list from January 1, 2018, and no Japanese maple, flowering cherry, crape myrtle or Norway spruce on it.
  • Connecticut Invasive Plant List: Connecticut Invasive Plant Working Group, University of Connecticut: Norway maple prohibited by statute from October 2030, and no Japanese maple, flowering cherry, crape myrtle or Norway spruce on the list.
  • Invasive Species: New Jersey Department of Agriculture, Division of Plant Industry: Norway maple first on the Prohibited Invasive Plant List, with the sale of listed plants barred from January 1, 2030.
  • Invasive Species Regulations: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, 6 NYCRR Part 575: Norway maple a regulated plant that must be sold under a warning label.
  • Virginia Invasive Plant Species List (PDF): Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation, Natural Heritage Program (2024): Norway maple ranked medium in invasiveness, and no Japanese maple, flowering cherry, crape myrtle or Norway spruce on the list.

Keep reading

Related articles

All articles