Blue Whale Trees
Find my tree

Pruning a pine, spruce, fir or cedar: what grows back, the lower branches, candles and a lost leader

By · Published · 6 min read

When to trim evergreens, why bottom branches cut from a spruce never return, how to keep a pine compact, shape an arborvitae and give a broken top a new one.

On this page Why a conifer cannot be cut back like an oakThe lower branches never come backPines: pinch the candles in springSpruces, firs and a lost leaderHemlocks, cedars and yews: which take shearingWhen to pruneKeeping a conifer small, or choosing one that fitsCommon questionsSources

Apart from yews, conifers grow new shoots only from buds in their green growth, so a cut has to stop where needles or a bud remain. A branch cut back into bare wood stays bare, and a lower limb taken off is gone for good. Pines are pinched in spring while their new shoots, the candles, are still soft. Spruces and firs are cut back to a side bud, while hemlocks, arborvitae and yews can be sheared within the green. Most native conifers need nothing but their dead wood removed.

Inside an old eastern red cedar’s crown, bare dark limbs carrying green foliage only on their outer twigs
An old eastern red cedar on May 20, 2024, bare inside with foliage only on its outer twigs. A cut into that bare wood leaves a gap that never fills. Photo: Blue Whale Trees

Why a conifer cannot be cut back like an oak

Oaks and most other hardwoods keep dormant buds under their bark and sprout after a hard cut, but pines, spruces, firs and hemlocks carry few and form none on a bare trunk. A conifer’s new shoots come from buds formed the year before, mostly at the tips of its twigs. Pines, spruces and firs set their branches in rings, or whorls, and grow in one flush a year. If you are unsure which conifer you have, the evergreen key tells them apart by needle and cone.

Shaded by the outer foliage, the older twigs inside the crown lose their needles and set no new buds. A cut into that bare middle, the dead zone, leaves a gap that never fills:

“This area is not really dead, but if pruning cuts are made into this area, there are no buds to sprout and fill in the gap produced by pruning.” (The Morton Arboretum, How to Prune Evergreen Trees and Shrubs)

Have a question about your own tree? Write to us.

The lower branches never come back

Once a pine, spruce or fir loses a lower limb, no new branch grows in its place. On a big tree most new growth is at the top, so the gap a cut limb leaves shows for many years.

Take a lower limb off only when it is dead or in the way. Cut it back to the trunk just outside its branch collar, in three cuts if it is heavy, and leave no stub.

A limb on a trunk, the finish cut just outside the ridge and collar, a flush cut and a stub crossed out, cuts numbered 1 to 3branch bark ridgecollar3flush cutstub12
On a heavy limb, cut 1 from below about a foot out, cut 2 from the top a little farther out, then cut 3 just outside the ridge and collar. A flush cut and a stub, crossed out, are the two errors. Drawing: Blue Whale Trees

In a group, red pine sheds its lower limbs on its own. A spruce that loses its lower branches one by one may be sick, since needle cast and canker both start low and climb.

Rows of tall, straight red pine trunks with reddish, plated bark, bare of branches far up and lit low by the sun
A red pine plantation in Monroe County, Pennsylvania, on September 12, 2015. In a group, red pine sheds its lower limbs on its own, and the bare trunk never grows new ones. Photo: Nicholas A. Tonelli, CC0 (source)

Pines: pinch the candles in spring

A pine makes its buds at the tips of its shoots, not along its stems, and grows once a year. In spring each tip bud stretches into a pale, upright shoot called a candle. Cut back past its needles, a pine branch grows no new shoot, and a shoot whose tip bud is cut stops growing.

To keep a pine dense or slow its growth, snap a third to two-thirds off each candle with your fingers, after it has stretched out but before its young needles spread. Pruners cut the young needles along the candle and leave them brown at the tips.

Never shear a pine, since cut needles stay cut. Jack pine, longleaf pine and Table Mountain pine need no pruning at all.

Pale new shoots of an eastern white pine standing upright from tufts of long, soft needles, their young needles held close
Candles on an eastern white pine in Ewing Township, New Jersey, on May 18, 2015. Snapping off a third to two-thirds of each at this stage keeps a pine dense. Photo: Famartin, CC BY-SA 4.0 (source)

Spruces, firs and a lost leader

Spruces and firs carry buds along their newest twigs as well as at the tips, so they take more cutting than a pine. To shorten a branch, cut it back to a small side branch or a bud you can see. Stay within the needles, and remove at the trunk a branch that must go back farther. Red spruce, balsam fir and Fraser fir need no pruning beyond dead wood.

When the leader, the topmost shoot, breaks, a side bud or a top branch may turn up to replace it. Keep one and cut back its rivals, or tie a top branch upright for a season if none turns up by itself. On a white pine, a leader killed by the weevil is cut out while the grubs are still inside. Never cut the leader to shorten a conifer: several leaders grow in its place, prone to damage from wind and snow.

Hemlocks, cedars and yews: which take shearing

Hemlocks, northern white cedar and yews carry hidden buds farther back along their stems. Those buds let them take shearing. Eastern hemlock, Carolina hemlock and northern white cedar, the wild arborvitae, all make a clipped hedge.

Extension services split on shearing. Some train arborvitae, hemlock and yew into formal hedges. Others cut one branch at a time, since shearing thickens the outer foliage and shades the inside bare. Either way, keep a hedge wider at its base than its top so light reaches the bottom branches. The spacing for a hedge is in native hedges, screens and windbreaks.

Yews differ: new growth comes from their old wood, so an overgrown yew can be cut back hard. Every part of a yew except the red flesh around the seed is poisonous to people, pets and livestock. Throw the clippings away.

Eastern red cedar, a juniper, and Atlantic white cedar need little pruning and are not sheared. To shape one, cut a branch back to an upward-growing side branch, where the cut hides under foliage. Cut into the bare wood inside and the hole is permanent.

A young eastern red cedar, dense and gray-green, its branches feathered all the way to the ground
A young eastern red cedar, dense with branches to the ground, on October 21, 2026. Red cedar is cut back to an upward side branch, never sheared. Photo: Blue Whale Trees

When to prune

Dead, broken and diseased branches can come off at any time of year. Foliage browned by winter waits until new growth shows. Every other cut has its season:

Cut When
Spruce and fir branches, back to a bud Late winter or early spring, before growth starts
Pine candles, pinched Mid-spring to early July, while still soft
Hemlocks, arborvitae and yews, sheared Spring as growth starts, lightly again in early summer
Juniper and cedar branches, back to a side branch Early spring, before growth starts
An overgrown yew, cut back hard Early spring, before growth starts
Where to cut a pine’s candles, a spruce twig and a cedar branch, with a cut into a cedar’s bare wood crossed outcandleside budbare woodPine: snap a thirdto two-thirds offeach candleSpruce or fir: cutback to a side budwithin the needlesCedar or juniper:cut to an upward sidebranch, never intobare wood
On a pine, snap a third to two-thirds off each candle. On a spruce or fir, cut back to a side bud within the needles. On a cedar or juniper, cut to an upward side branch, never into bare wood. Drawing: Blue Whale Trees

Avoid cutting in late summer and fall, and cut no yew after July, since a late cut can wake new growth that will not harden before winter. A few boughs cut for holiday greens in winter usually do no harm.

Keeping a conifer small, or choosing one that fits

Pruning will not hold a big conifer to a small size:

“Pruning may make the new growth bushier but will not effectively control size.” (Colorado State University Extension, Pruning Evergreens)

Eastern white pine, a native we do not grow, becomes an enormous tree that no pruning keeps small. Hardwoods are made shorter with reduction cuts, as pruning at the branch collar explains, but pines, spruces and firs take only light ones. A conifer that needs cutting every year to stay out of a walk, a drive or a view is the wrong tree for the spot. These natives stay small:

  • Creeping juniper: a low mat for dry, sunny ground. Zones 2 to 9, 1 to 2 feet.
  • Common juniper: a spreading shrub for dry, sunny ground. Zones 2 to 9, 2 to 10 feet.
  • Canada yew: a low evergreen for shade. Zones 2 to 7, 3 to 6 feet.
  • Florida yew: a small tree for shade or sun. Zones 6 to 10, 12 to 25 feet.

Blue Whale Trees grows all four from seed. If you are unsure where a cut should go, write to us through the support page with a photo of the whole tree and a close-up of the branch.

Common questions

Can you cut the bottom branches off a spruce tree?

Yes, if they are dead or in the way, but they never grow back. Cut each at the trunk just outside the swollen collar at its base, leaving no stub.

When is the best time to prune pine trees?

Pinch the new shoots, the candles, between mid-spring and early July, while they are still soft. Dead or broken branches can come off at any time, but avoid other cuts in late summer and fall.

Can you trim a spruce tree to keep it small?

Only a little: cutting branch tips back to a side bud each spring makes a spruce denser, but the tree keeps growing taller from its top. A spruce that must be cut back every year is better replaced with a smaller conifer.

Can you cut back an overgrown arborvitae?

Only as far as the green: northern white cedar, the wild arborvitae, regrows from buds within its foliage but not from the bare brown wood inside. An arborvitae far too big for its place is better replaced.

Share Copy link Email this article

Support

Have a question about your own tree?

Describe the tree, the site and what you are seeing. A photo of the whole tree and a close-up of the problem help.

Write to us

Shipping windows, newly priced plants and new articles. Four to six emails a year, and nothing else.

Sources

(5 references)
  • How to Prune Evergreen Trees and Shrubs: The Morton Arboretum: the dead zone inside the crown and the quotation on it, new growth from buds formed the year before at the twig tips, whorled branching, candles and their pinching, no growth from a pine’s woody stems, buds along the newest twigs of spruce and fir, a lost leader replaced, buds hidden in arborvitae’s branch crotches, shearing that thickens the outer foliage, yew’s growth from old wood and its renewal in spring, no yew cut after July, and no cuts in late summer or fall.
  • Pruning Evergreens: Colorado State University Extension (CMG GardenNotes #617): the quotation on size, limbs taken up only when in the way, growth mostly at the top of a big tree, branches cut back to the trunk outside the collar in three cuts, spruce and fir cut within the needles in late winter or early spring, candles snapped by hand since pruners brown the needles, a cut tip bud that stops a shoot, no shearing of pines, several leaders after a cut leader, juniper and arborvitae cut back to an upward side branch, bare wood left bare, and replacing an evergreen that needs constant cutting.
  • Pruning Needled Evergreens: Penn State Extension (2024): lower branches that never regrow, no growth from brown wood except on yews, arborvitae, hemlock and yew trained into sheared hedges with a light summer trim, a hedge wider at the base, half to two-thirds of a candle from June to early July, yew trimmings thrown away, and eastern white pine too big to keep small.
  • Pruning Evergreens: University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension (Laura Jull): a pine’s buds only at the tips of the current growth, half to two-thirds of a candle before the needles expand, spruce and fir cut to a side bud, latent buds farther back on hemlock, arborvitae and yew, a hedge wider at the base, and junipers and false cypress cut back to a side branch and never sheared.
  • A Guide to Successful Pruning, Pruning Evergreen Trees: Virginia Cooperative Extension (Susan C. French and Bonnie Lee Appleton, 430-457): one flush of growth a year on whorl-branched conifers, no cuts into the bare center, candles pinched by hand in mid to late spring since shears brown the young needles, no pruning in late summer and early fall, and winter cuts for decorating that do no harm.

Keep reading

Related articles

All articles