Blue Whale Trees
Find my tree

Key

What evergreen is this? A key to the native pines, spruces, firs, hemlocks, cedars and junipers by needle and cone

By · Published · 9 min read

A key to eastern evergreens: count the needles in a pine's bundle, tell a spruce from a fir or hemlock, sort the three cedars, and find conifers that go bare.

On this page Bundles, single needles or scalesNeedles in bundles: the pinesTwo needles to a bundleThree or five to a bundleFour-sided needles on pegs: red spruceFlat needles: firs and hemlocksYews and torreya: seeds in place of conesScales: the three cedars and the junipersNeedles that fall in autumnWhen the needle is not enoughCommon questionsSources

Look first at how the needles meet the twig. Needles held together at the base in bundles of two, three or five belong to a pine. Single needles belong to a spruce, fir, hemlock or yew. Of those, only a spruce needle is four-sided and set on a tiny woody peg. Tiny scales pressed against the twig mark the three native cedars, and soft needles in tufts on short spurs mark tamarack, which drops them every fall.

Sunlit sprays of a young eastern hemlock seen from above, short flat needles set in two rows along each twig
A young eastern hemlock on October 20, 2022. Its flat needles, about half an inch long, grow one at a time in two rows along each twig. Photo: Blue Whale Trees

Jump to what you hold: Bundles · Pegs · Flat needles · Yews · Scales · Bare in winter

Bundles, single needles or scales

Pull a few needles from a branch tip and look at their base. A pine’s needles come away together, two, three or five in a bundle, or fascicle, held at the base by a sheath. Spruces, firs, hemlocks and yews carry their needles one at a time, spiraled around the twig or spread in two flat rows. Conifers are the easiest trees to key out, and a good place to learn how a key works:

“Identifying conifers, or needle-bearing trees, is the easiest and a good choice to learn how to use identification keys.” (Michigan State University Extension, Conifer Key)

The three native cedars and creeping juniper wear tiny overlapping scales in place of needles, and common juniper carries sharp needles three to a joint. On tamarack, soft needles grow 10 to 20 together from short spur shoots. Tamarack drops them all in fall, as bald cypress and pond cypress do. An evergreen with broad leaves, such as a holly or a magnolia, is a broadleaf tree, and the leaf key sorts it instead.

Needles in bundles: the pines

Count the needles in a bundle, then measure one. Within each count, the rows run from the shortest needles to the longest. We do not grow eastern white pine or loblolly pine, and each has a page of its own.

Two needles to a bundle

Trees Needles Cone Look for
Jack pine ¾ to 1½ inches, twisted and spread apart Curved, 1½ to 2 inches, shut for years Dark gray, scaly bark
Table Mountain pine 1½ to 3½ inches, stout and twisted Heavy, 1.7 to 4.1 inches, each scale with a stout, curved spine Cones in whorls of two to seven
Spruce pine 1½ to 4 inches, soft and slender 1 to 2 inches, with a small prickle Bark ridged like a spruce’s
Sand pine 2 to 3 inches, slightly twisted 2 to 3½ inches, short prickles, often shut A small, bushy tree of dry sand
Red pine 4 to 6 inches, snapping cleanly when bent 1½ to 2½ inches, no prickles Reddish, plated bark
Jack pine branch with two curved, closed cones among short, twisted needles held two to a bundle
Jack pine in Acadia National Park, Maine, on July 7, 2016. Its needles grow two to a bundle, ¾ to 1½ inches long, and its curved cones can stay shut for years. Photo: Doug McGrady, CC BY 2.0 (source)

Scots pine, planted from Europe, carries two needles under 2 inches long, as jack pine does, but its bark is orange-brown where jack pine’s is dark gray. We do not grow Scots pine.

Three or five to a bundle

Trees Needles Cone Look for
Pond pine 3, sometimes 4, 4 to 7 inches Round, 2 to 3 inches, shut for years Sprouts along the trunk
Loblolly pine 3, 6 to 10 inches 3 to 6 inches, sharp spines Cones in groups of one to three
Longleaf pine 3, 8 to 18 inches 6 to 10 inches, the largest in the East Large silvery-white buds
Eastern white pine 5, 3 to 5 inches, soft and bluish green 4 to 8 inches, slender and resinous Fine white lines on each needle

Pond pine can be hard to tell from loblolly pine at sapling size. We do not grow pitch, shortleaf, Virginia or slash pine either, and each of those has a page of its own.

Four-sided needles on pegs: red spruce

Roll a spruce needle between finger and thumb and it turns on its four sides. Red spruce has sharp, shiny yellow-green needles ½ to ⅝ inch long that tend to curve upward. Each sits on a raised woody peg, so a twig stripped of its needles is covered in short pegs. The reddish brown cones, 1 to 2 inches long, drop soon after they ripen in fall.

Two reddish brown red spruce cones hanging among short, sharp, yellow-green needles on a branch
Red spruce cones among its short needles. Each needle is four-sided and sits on a woody peg, and the cones drop soon after they ripen in fall. Photo: Robert H. Mohlenbrock, Public domain (source)

White spruce and black spruce, northern spruces we do not grow, carry the same pegs. White spruce has hairless twigs, while the new twigs of black spruce are hairy and red spruce’s are finely hairy. Norway spruce, planted from Europe and not grown by us, bears cones 4 to 6 inches long, far longer than red spruce’s.

Flat needles: firs and hemlocks

Firs and hemlocks both carry flat needles, dark green above and silvery or white-lined beneath. Pull one off: a fir needle has no stalk and leaves a flat, round scar, while a hemlock needle sits on a short stalk of its own. Fir cones stand upright on the branch and shed their scales and seeds there, leaving the bare woody core.

Upright purplish balsam fir cones beaded with white resin, standing on a branch tip among short, flat needles
Balsam fir cones on Niapiskau Island, Quebec, on August 23, 2012. They stand upright, purple when young, and shed their scales with the seed from late summer into fall. Photo: Cephas, CC BY-SA 3.0 (source)

The table runs from the firs to the hemlocks. A hemlock needle shows two white lines of stomata beneath.

Trees Needles Cone Look for
Balsam fir ¾ inch, blunt or notched, no stalk Upright, purplish, 2 to 4 inches, bracts mostly hidden Smooth bark with raised resin blisters
Fraser fir ¾ to 1 inch, blunt or notched, more crowded on the twig Upright, dark purple, 1½ to 2½ inches, pale bracts curled down over the scales Wild on southern Appalachian peaks
Eastern hemlock ½ inch, on a short stalk, in two flat rows ½ to ¾ inch A drooping top shoot
Carolina hemlock ½ to ¾ inch, on a short stalk, all around the twig 1 to 1½ inches, scales spreading wide Appalachian cliffs
Carolina hemlock branch whose short, glossy needles stand out all around the twig, hazy mountains behind
Carolina hemlock on Stone Mountain, North Carolina, on October 25, 2008. It sets its needles all around the twig like a bottlebrush, where eastern hemlock lays them in two flat rows. Photo: Adam Lynch, CC BY-SA 2.0 (source)

Fraser fir was once counted a variety of balsam fir, and the cone is what now tells them apart. On Fraser fir the bracts are much longer than the scales and bend down over them, while on balsam fir they mostly hide between the scales. Eastern hemlock lays its needles in two flat rows, and Carolina hemlock sets them all around the twig like a bottlebrush.

Yews and torreya: seeds in place of cones

Yews and torreya carry flat, pointed needles too, but their seeds sit alone, not in a woody cone. A yew’s seed rests in a red, fleshy cup called an aril, open at the tip. Canada yew is also called ground hemlock, but it grows as a low shrub, and its needles are paler beneath with a green midvein.

Bright red, cup-shaped Canada yew arils among sprays of flat, dark green needles
Canada yew holds each seed in a red, cup-shaped aril up to ⅜ inch long, open at the tip and ripe from July into September. Photo: Ayotte, Gilles, 1948-, CC BY-SA 4.0 (source)
Trees Needles Seed Look for
Canada yew ⅜ to 1 inch, paler beneath with a green midvein In a red aril, July to September A low shrub of deep shade, 3 to 6 feet
Florida yew About 1 inch, ending in an abrupt point In a red aril, on female plants A small tree; male and female plants are separate
Florida torreya Stiff, glossy and sharp-tipped, smelling rank when crushed Purple-streaked Apalachicola River bluffs

Scales: the three cedars and the junipers

Three native trees called cedar belong to three different genera. Eastern red cedar is a juniper, and northern white cedar is the wild arborvitae. Atlantic white cedar is the only false cypress native to the eastern states. All three wear scales, and so does creeping juniper.

Flat sprays of northern white cedar scale leaves with small brown cones opened like little flowers
Northern white cedar at Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore, Michigan, on September 18, 2019. Its scales grow in flat sprays, and its small upright cones open like little roses. Photo: NPS, Public domain (source)
Trees Leaves Cone Look for
Eastern red cedar Tiny scales held tight to the twig; sharp needles on young growth Berrylike, ¼ inch, frosted blue, on female trees only Red-brown bark peeling in long strips
Northern white cedar Scales in flat, spreading sprays Upright, ⅓ to ½ inch, opening like little roses Fibrous bark in a diamond pattern
Atlantic white cedar Tiny blue-green scales on slender shoots, not in flat sprays Round, ¼ inch, bluish purple to brown A slender spire on wet ground
Common juniper Sharp needles in threes, each with a silver band Berrylike, blue-black with a pale bloom A low, spreading shrub
Creeping juniper Scales pressed close in four rows, purplish in winter Berrylike, dark blue, on curved stalks A mat 1 to 2 feet high

Northern white cedar and Atlantic white cedar are the two most alike. Northern white cedar holds its scales in flat sprays and its cones stand upright, while Atlantic white cedar’s shoots branch every way and its cones are round. Only female eastern red cedars bear the frosted blue cones, so a tree without them may be a male. Native hedges and screens gives the spacing for a screen of the three.

Pale blue, berrylike common juniper cones among sharp, yellow-green needles
Common juniper in Algoma District, Ontario, on July 25, 2010. It bears sharp needles three to a joint and berrylike cones that take two or three years to ripen. Photo: Fungus Guy, CC BY-SA 3.0 (source)

Needles that fall in autumn

Three native conifers drop every needle each fall, and a bare one is not a dead one. Tamarack turns gold from early September and stands bare by mid-October. Dawn redwood, a planted look-alike we do not grow, is told from bald cypress in bald cypress or dawn redwood.

Trees Needles Cone Look for
Tamarack ¾ to 1 inch, soft, 10 to 20 to a spur Upright, ½ to ¾ inch Bogs and wet northern ground
Bald cypress ¼ to ¾ inch, in two flat rows, the shoot like a feather Round, breaking apart when ripe Knees and a fluted base
Pond cypress ⅜ inch, awl-like, pressed along shoots that point upward Round, ¾ to 1 inch A swollen base and thick, furrowed bark
Tamaracks turned gold in a bog in autumn, red shrubs below and green conifers behind
Tamaracks turning gold in a bog in Sand Lake, New York, on October 17, 2024. Their needles yellow from early September and drop by mid-October. Photo: Famartin, CC BY-SA 4.0 (source)

Pond cypress is the hard one to place, since its seedlings and fast shoots can carry flat rows of needles like a bald cypress’s. Silvics of North America ranks the two as varieties of one species and gives a warning:

“Despite the usual differences in appearance between the two varieties, not all specimens are typical, and it is often difficult and sometimes impossible to distinguish them […].” (USDA Forest Service, Baldcypress)

When the needle is not enough

Needles change as a tree grows, and eastern red cedar’s young shoots carry sharp needles in place of scales. Work from a grown tree where one stands:

“It is best to use a mature tree, or one that is not a seedling or sapling.” (Michigan State University Extension, Conifer Key)

A young eastern red cedar in a woods, its feathery shoots covered in short, prickly, needlelike leaves
A young eastern red cedar on October 16, 2024. Its shoots carry prickly, needlelike leaves about ¼ inch long, where a grown tree's leaves are mostly tiny, overlapping scales. Photo: Blue Whale Trees

Cones on the ground narrow the list further, and what tree dropped this keys them by shape. For the bare broadleaf trees beside them, winter identification reads twigs, buds and bark. To get a name from a photo, try the tree identification tool. Photograph a branch tip from above and from below, then a cone, and add the tree’s height, your state and the month in the box under the photos.

Blue Whale Trees grows every conifer in the tables but the few each section names as ones we do not. The native trees by state tool lists which of the trees we grow the USDA records growing wild in your state, a short list to check a name against.

Common questions

How do you tell a spruce from a fir?

Roll a needle between your fingers: a spruce needle is four-sided and sharp, and it sits on a small woody peg. A fir needle is flat and leaves a round scar when pulled off, and fir cones stand upright on the branch.

How many needles are in a pine bundle?

Two, three or five, depending on the pine. Red, jack, sand, spruce and Table Mountain pine carry two. Longleaf and loblolly pine carry three, pond pine three or sometimes four, and eastern white pine five.

How do you tell a hemlock from a spruce?

A hemlock needle is flat, about half an inch long, with two white lines beneath and a short stalk of its own. A spruce needle is four-sided and sharp on a woody peg, and an eastern hemlock’s cones are under an inch long.

How do you tell eastern red cedar from northern white cedar?

Northern white cedar holds its scales in flat sprays and bears small upright cones that open like little roses. Eastern red cedar’s scales cling tight to slender shoots, and its female trees bear frosted blue berrylike cones.

Which pine has the longest needles?

Among the pines in this key, longleaf pine, whose needles grow 8 to 18 inches long, three to a bundle, in tufts at the branch tips. Loblolly pine’s reach 6 to 10 inches and pond pine’s 4 to 7.

Share Copy link Email this article

Tool

Is it native where you live?

Pick a state and see which of our trees and shrubs the USDA records growing wild there, with the ones native only to part of the country listed apart.

Open the native trees by state tool

Shipping windows, newly priced plants and new articles. Four to six emails a year, and nothing else.

Sources

(5 references)
  • Conifer Key: Michigan State University Extension, U.P. Tree Identification Key, hosted by Michigan Technological University: the two quotations, needles in bundles against single needles, eastern white pine’s five needles, jack pine’s dark gray bark against Scots pine’s orange-brown and needles under 2 inches, the hemlock needle’s short stalk against the stalkless fir needle, and the twigs of white and black spruce.
  • Red spruce: Virginia Tech Dendrology, with its fact sheets for jack, Table Mountain, spruce, sand, red, pond and longleaf pine, balsam and Fraser fir, eastern and Carolina hemlock, eastern red cedar, northern and Atlantic white cedar, tamarack, bald cypress and pond cypress: the needles, cones, twigs and bark in the tables, red spruce’s four-sided needles on pegs, the firs’ flat leaf scars and eastern red cedar’s needlelike young leaves.
  • Baldcypress: USDA Forest Service, Silvics of North America, with the chapters on Fraser fir and pond pine: the quotation on telling bald cypress from pond cypress, pond cypress’s two-ranked seedling leaves, Fraser fir once counted a variety of balsam fir and told from it by bracts longer than the scales, and pond pine hard to tell from loblolly pine at sapling size.
  • Pinus strobus: NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, with its pages for loblolly pine, Norway spruce, Fraser fir, eastern red cedar, Canada yew, Florida yew, Florida torreya and creeping juniper: the needles and cones of eastern white pine and loblolly pine, Norway spruce’s cones, Fraser fir’s needle length, eastern red cedar’s prickly young leaves, the yews’ arils and needles, the torreya’s needles, and creeping juniper’s scales and cones.
  • Tamarack: The Morton Arboretum, with its pages on eastern arborvitae, common juniper, Scots pine and Norway spruce: tamarack’s soft needles in bundles of 10 to 20, arborvitae’s flat sprays of overlapping scales, common juniper’s sharp leaves in whorls of three, and Scots pine and Norway spruce as trees from Europe.

Keep reading

Related articles

All articles